Gabriel Kießling and Dr. Ute Buth in conversation

… or only very quietly, behind a raised hand. At the same time, advertising, movies, series and short videos on social media talk about sex all the time. How children and teenagers deal with sexuality being everywhere in their language, and what stance parents, educators, leaders and churches can take: Dr. Ute Buth (gynecologist and author of sex education books for children) and Gabriel Kießling (religious and church educator) talk about this together. Both are specialist speakers at Weisses Kreuz.

This conversation first appeared in the Weisses Kreuz magazine on sexuality and language (issue 92). More on the topic there (in German).

Gabriel Kießling (GK): Three years ago I preached to 230 confirmation students. At the end of the sermon, the word “pornography” came up. I noticed right away how the back third of the room got restless and suddenly had a lot to laugh about. Their reaction surprised me and threw me. That word seemed to have triggered something. Why do teenagers react like that? After all, pornography isn’t a topic that doesn’t exist in their lives.

*Ute Buth (UB):* To me that sounds like a kind of irritation that they covered up with laughter. Pornography is a big topic. The chances are pretty high that they know something about it, maybe have even come across it themselves. Now the word suddenly comes up in the context of church, which they might not expect to be able to talk about this topic at all. And it gets very close to them. That feeling of surprise is probably easiest to cover up with humor.

*GK:* So a completely normal reaction?

Teenagers seen from behind sitting in the back row of a classroom, facing the front
Why do teenagers react like that? After all, pornography isn’t a topic that doesn’t exist in their lives. Photo: Sam Balye

UB: I see that many children don’t learn good language for sexuality at home. In my view, good sex education is a lifestyle, not an appointment. Children are well off if they already learn at home that you can talk about sex in a good way. When parents, often with really good intentions, want to protect their children from the topic, some choose the bell jar model, at least for a while: keep the child away from the topic as long as possible, until they’re “older” and/or school takes over the job. In my view, though, that doesn’t really work. At school, sex education projects usually happen in third or fourth grade. The chances that children have long been “educated” by others by then are huge: by other children on the playground or on the way to school, in their free time, through the internet and so on. Strictly speaking, the bell jar model would mean no outside contact for the child and locking them up at home. That’s not possible. Which also makes clear that this strategy hasn’t been thought through.

We live in a sexualized world. We can’t stop information from reaching children. But we can certainly lay good foundations and start age-appropriate conversations. By the way, silence about sexuality also speaks a loud and clear language, but a rather destructive one: We don’t talk about that! That may also have happened with the teenagers you just told me about. But again: I’m absolutely in favor of parents knowing how important it is for children to have age-appropriate language.

*GK:* What does age-appropriate language in sex education look like?

*UB:* When I offer sex education projects at elementary schools or seminars for parents and educators, I don’t use cute nicknames. Otherwise children risk not being understood. Terms like these can have meanings that only make sense inside one family, or they’re so vague that a child can’t even say what happened if someone abuses them. I encourage people to use the correct terms and at the same time to realize that these are still totally abstract for small children. That’s why, wherever possible, I build a bridge into the children’s world. In my sex education picture book Erklärt mir mal, wo komm ich her? (“Explain to Me: Where Do I Come From?”, in German), for example, I explain: “Every woman has a room in her tummy, the room called the uterus. That’s where the baby grows. And when the time comes for the baby to come out, it’s born through the passage called the vagina.” Children can picture a passage and a room, and at the same time they’ve learned the correct words “uterus” and “vagina.”

First information sticks much more strongly than what comes after it.

*GK:* How does that change as they get older?

*UB:* Of course teenagers in particular don’t want to be treated like small children. In class, it’s first about finding a shared language with them: What terms do they know? What sounds respectful? What sounds demeaning? Which words do we use so that everyone can join in? At the same time, we never know what foundations were laid at home. You might also assume too much knowledge. That’s why it’s important to name the basics in any case, so teenagers can check their half-knowledge against them and don’t end up embarrassed or left behind.

*GK:* You’re describing the phenomenon of too little: There are no terms, or only strange ones. Is there also the phenomenon of too much, where a six-year-old has already been told about sex practices by their parents?

UB: Or by movies. Or by other children. In preschool, a five-year-old says to his buddy: “Now I know where babies come from. The man puts his penis in the woman’s vagina or in her mouth.” And everyone wonders: “Where did he get that information?” Yes, there really are homes where parents watch porn during the day too and let the children watch along, maybe not even aware that this is a crime. Many parents tend to put on the brakes and say: “My children are still too young,” and fend off their questions. But questions don’t go away when you meet them with silence.

A little girl whispers something into a boy’s ear behind her hand, and he grins
Many parents tend to put on the brakes and say: “My children are still too young,” and fend off their questions. But questions don’t go away when you meet them with silence. Photo: saeed karimi

Whether it’s too much, for example through porn, or too little, through silence and fending off questions: First information sticks much more strongly than what comes after it. Without good basic knowledge, porn films or other strange information about sex can’t be put into context and have a very strong effect.

To develop good language for this, I developed “Sexualaufklärung – Aufgabe und Chance” (Sex Education: Task and Opportunity, in German). Parents should realize that they don’t have a monopoly on sex education. Most of them don’t look back on a good experience of sex education themselves. Parents can then be equipped and supported in when and how they can start conversations with their children. Reflection is important here: What shaped how I learned about sex? What did my family of origin, my faith, the culture I come from do to my understanding of sexuality? What do I think about sex? Which aspects are important to me, and which haven’t I grasped at all yet?

Then they can think about which parts of what they know they actually want to pass on consciously in their children’s sex education, and why.

*GK:* So that means: The more I reflect on myself, the better I can put sexual topics into words in a good way. Good sex education is then like a reference point for children, where they can compare what they hear later. And when they’re confused, they know: I can go to my parents and ask them, because I know there’s room for that there. Just because the parents talk, they open up that room for their children.

That takes courage, especially when I realize: I’ve missed something there, I don’t even know what my daughter already knows about sex and what she thinks about it. We adults carry the responsibility to take the initiative here and offer this room for talking.

A mother with glasses reads a book with her daughter, who leans her head on her
We adults carry the responsibility to take the initiative here and offer this room for talking. Photo: Unsplash+

*UB:* And the hurdle to do it for the first time doesn’t get smaller as the children get older. Some also shy away from it because they’re put off by sexual terms in children’s and teenagers’ everyday language.

*GK:* Sexualized language isn’t only an expression of ignorance or insecurity and of bad or insufficient sex education by parents. It’s also used quite deliberately to set themselves apart from the adult world. The more offensive or unspeakable something is considered, the more often it’s used among teenagers. And the more vehemently adults speak out against it, the better it does its job: You have nothing to tell us. This is our world, not yours. Many people see helping teenagers find good language about sexuality as an Olympic sport that’s best left to the professionals.

*UB:* Yes, and at the same time it also depends on your role. Is the person telling me this someone I feel I need to set myself apart from? It makes a huge difference whether you’re there as a youth worker or as a dad, and how well people think you can talk about it. When I talked with a ninth-grade class about the effects of pornography, something really interesting happened. During the break, one of the cool guys came straight to me and said: “I’d just like to know more about that.” And then he asked questions. And you could tell how it was working inside him and that he suddenly had a way to see porn differently. In my role as a mother, this conversation would have been much harder, or maybe even impossible without a shared language.

*GK:* But the role then has to come with the right behavior. Teenagers notice quickly whether they matter to me as people or only their behavior does. Once we were sitting in our youth group, and the word “jerk-off” kept coming up as a supposedly funny name for each other. I can forbid it and punish it (control the behavior), or I can ask: “Do you feel this is a respectful way to treat each other? Is this a good way for you to talk to each other?” (interest in the person)

*UB:* Exactly. When teenagers use (swear) words that put others down, that isn’t nice. But if you respond in a way that puts them down, nothing is gained. At that point I also think it’s good to ask: What are we actually expressing through language?

Two young men stand face to face, close together, and look at each other tensely
At that point I also think it’s good to ask: What are we actually expressing through language? Photo: Unsplash+

*GK:* Absolutely. Because abuse always starts with language too. If, as a child or teenager, I’m used to just being a “bitch” and sexualized words like that don’t trigger anything in me anymore, I’m heading into dangerous waters. Where I’ve been desensitized through language, I’m missing the warning systems for other kinds of abuse. How do you see that?

*UB:* Yes, of course. Because abusers also notice how someone talks, or how someone sets boundaries, when you use crude, sexualized language. That’s deliberately used when abusers are grooming someone for sexual violence.

*GK:* If parents tend to underestimate how much sex education their children need, and if language shows what’s already going on inside, then that means: My child’s sexualized language points to a high interest in information about adult sexuality. Then I know: We need to tackle this.

*UB:* A child who doesn’t ask is a black box. You don’t even know whether any sexual topics have already landed in there. Maybe the child thinks: “I could never in my life tell Mom and Dad this! Because then they’ll definitely want to know how I know, and then I’d have to admit what I do and watch with my friends.” And from the outside the parents think: He’s only a first grader, he’s nowhere near having anything to do with sex.

It’s so important to equip children with good language. In my new book about puberty and pregnancy, #Respektvoll leben – eine Sommercamp-Geschichte – mit Pubertätsguide (Living Respectfully: A Summer Camp Story with a Puberty Guide, in German), children in the story also see, among other things, adults who can talk about it. It was important to me that there are role models of people you can approach. Sadly, many children don’t experience that at home yet. My heart beats for winning even more parents for this.

*GK:* How can I do this as someone responsible in a school or church?

*UB:* When you tell parents they “have to” give their child sex education, they often feel controlled and feel you’re stepping on their territory. Then a wall can go up quickly, and what comes back is: “You have no business telling me what to do.” And that’s true. But when parents understand what family of origin, faith, culture and so on do to how we learn about sex, and when they understand who and what all is teaching their children about it, the same parents often say on their own: “Oh, I think we need to do something. What can I do?” The motivation for children to grow up well in this area is often followed by the will to change something. Then they need the building blocks they’re missing to start with knowledge and courage.

*GK:* So that means: Fear of their children developing badly when it comes to sexuality is often what motivates parents. But it’s a negative emotion. The positive ones are much more powerful. Especially for churches, but for families too, I wish for much less warning about the possible missteps and much more promotion of and excitement for God’s brilliant idea of sexuality. We should talk much more about the beauty of sexuality than about its dangers. Then parents could become more and more motivated to prepare their child’s sexuality in a good way, like a garden. Then there’s a chance that my child won’t have to come to you for counseling at 30.

Gabriel Kießling is a religious and church educator, a specialist speaker and youth speaker at Weisses Kreuz, a father of three, and gives talks in youth groups.

Dr. Ute Buth is a counselor and speaker for Weisses Kreuz, a gynecologist, a sex counselor certified by the German Society for Sex Research (DGfS) and a mother of two adult children. The author of books including Erklärt mir mal, wo komm ich her? teaches sex education projects at different types of schools.