Cultural narratives are fed to us in bite-size pieces, easily, through thousands of entertaining messages. The many hours teens spend online, and the messages, slogans and opinions they consume there, have enormous power to shape them and change how they see themselves and the world.

That’s nothing new so far. But according to a Barna study, churches still don’t seem to have fully grasped how strongly the online world shapes teens’ thoughts and feelings, and what that means, for example, for everyday church life, evangelism and the role of youth leaders. The commentary on the study puts it pointedly: teens live in digital Babylon.¹ In the digital space they’re surrounded by a culture that is critical of their own worldview, where their convictions come under pressure and where it’s challenging to live out their faith consistently. Society increasingly no longer sees us Christians as those slightly odd people who don’t have sex before marriage and give away part of their income, but as dangerous, because we stand against the secular idea of what a good life looks like. In society’s eyes we’re backward and repressive, and therefore harmful.

Of course there’s also a lot of secular content on social media that is good and worthwhile. Still, I believe this pointed image of the digital space as “digital Babylon” helps us understand Gen Z’s challenges better and reach them more intentionally.

The central challenge is how we can counter the enormous shaping power of social media. According to one study from Germany, teens spend about 70 hours a week online in total.² That’s a serious number. And sorry, but it’s simply naive and unrealistic to think that the two or three hours teens spend at youth group and church are enough to replace the secular narratives. Most churches just can’t keep up in quality or quantity. So it’s hardly surprising when teens aren’t being formed into the image of Jesus, but into the ideal social media paints. Depending on the bubble teens move in, that can be super woke and left-liberal or shockingly restrictive and conservative.

One building block for a missional awakening in Generation Z is resilient disciples: teens who have an intimate relationship with Jesus in a complex society and can speak prophetically into the culture, because they recognize what in it is good, what is bad, what is missing and what is twisted.

To help teens build resilience, grow spiritually and live missionally, it can help to rethink two areas of youth ministry: the role of youth leaders and the role of the youth group in evangelism.

The youth leader as content curator

Youth leaders become content curators. Unlike the classic model, where the youth leader mainly passes on knowledge and motivation through a devotional or sermon in a group setting, they now recommend content to their teens that already exists on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok or other platforms. That might be short sermon clips on YouTube, TikTok videos, Insta posts or a song on Spotify. During the week they pass it on to the group, or to individuals when needed, and comment on it and put it in context. By now there’s quite a lot of Christian content, and there are Christian content creators you can draw on. For example, you can put together YouTube playlists on the topic “How do you understand the Bible correctly?” Or a Spotify playlist of selected worship songs that deal with suffering and challenges and encourage teens in difficult times.

As a content curator, you create an ongoing learning experience that helps teens hold on to Jesus’ truths in everyday life and let themselves be shaped by Jesus’ truths rather than by secular narratives.

You’re also acknowledging what happens with most teens anyway: they personalize their faith in the digital sphere. There, they’re detached from the four walls of the church, and so from the church’s taste, but also from its identity. They can listen to whatever worship they want. They can listen to whatever sermons they want, from whomever they want. Faith the way it suits them.

The youth leader as content curator understands this process and, on the one hand, helps them personalize their faith by offering a broad buffet of content that teens can help themselves to.

On the other hand, she also points out the limits and downsides of the hyper-individualism behind it. That’s the role of the culture critic.

The youth leader as culture critic

A culture critic doesn’t mean someone who talks all the time about the “oh so evil world” out there and sees a sign of the end times behind every TikTok trend. Critic here means the position a literary critic takes, for example. She appreciates the beautiful and good passages but also points out the weaknesses and mistakes. We show what the culture has rightly recognized, such as the strong desire to live together peacefully through tolerance, but we also show why tolerance ultimately reaches its limits and can’t bring about that peaceful life together, and how Jesus, with his command to love our enemies, even goes beyond it.

Like in a biopsy, the culture critic dissects secular “messages of salvation” like “Just be yourself!” and explains where these statements come from, what’s good about them, what’s problematic and maybe even what philosophical premises or implications they contain.

Of course, you don’t have to give sociology lectures in youth group. You can break it down to the situation at hand and work it into your devotional or sermon. Or integrate it into your role as content curator by sharing pop culture content that answers questions like “What does a good, fulfilling life look like?” or “What makes a person who they are at their core?” differently than Jesus does. Afterward you can comment on the content together with your teens and question it. At the same time, teens learn how to consume content critically.

We need teens who know why they believe and why the gospel is the more beautiful, better and truer story. Commenting critically on the culture can help teens grow in their own faith, because they put down firm roots in Jesus. That way they come to a faith in which they can clearly draw the line between themselves and the half-truths and empty promises of secularism, and build a deep trust in Jesus’ truths.

That’s why pastor and author Tim Keller says we need a new kind of catechism.³ There’s a reason the Protestant catechisms written with and after Luther give less space to the Trinity and much more space to topics related to the doctrine of justification. The catechisms weren’t simply written to record basic, internal statements of faith, but also to set themselves apart from the Catholic Church of the time. And so to set themselves apart from what was then the only real alternative worldview.

Today the dominant alternative to Christian faith is the secular worldview. That’s why Keller notes that we need new catechisms that do something similar to the first Protestant ones. Catechisms that respond not to Catholic dogma but to secular dogma.

Dogmas like:
“You’re free to live however you want, as long as it doesn’t hurt anyone else.” Or:
“Do what makes you happy, and don’t sacrifice your happiness for others.” Or:
“Everyone has the right to decide for themselves what is good and right for them.”

Dogmas teens encounter several times a day: in music, in shows, in ads, in posts, in movies and so on. And even though many of these dogmas contain truths and often even have their origins in Christianity, in the end they stand against the teaching of Jesus, and so against a fulfilled life.

All of us, consciously or unconsciously, have a working hypothesis of how hearts are changed. In many churches and youth groups, this hypothesis is: “Preach the Bible in an inspiring, entertaining way, and then they should go out and apply it.” In digital Babylon and for Gen Z, that’s no longer enough.

If we leave out the connection to the secular worldview, the culture critique, teens simply integrate the messages into their worldview and don’t even understand how radically different the way of Jesus really is.

Or they reject the message, consciously or unconsciously, because they can’t fit it into the narratives they know. Gen Z wants to know: Why is what you’re saying true? Why does it make a difference? How does this truth change my life? And for that, culture critique is simply essential.

The famous singer-songwriter Leonard Cohen, whose work is full of Christian references, writes these lines in his song “Anthem”:

*Ring the bells that still can ring
Forget your perfect offering
There is a crack,
a crack in everything
That’s how the light gets in*

In a complex time, and in the face of the many crises teens see themselves in, the cracks in a secular, hyper-individualistic and naturalistic worldview are becoming clearer. Teens see and feel that too. Through these cracks we can let the light of the gospel into teens’ world. For the light to break through, our first step is to show our Christian teens what these cracks are and why the gospel is a better alternative. That makes them resilient disciples in a complex world and then, in a second step, witnesses who can put their faith into words.

Because to show their non-Christian friends that they have a problem that cries out for redemption, they first have to show that their current answers don’t hold up.

And not in an “evil, evil world” kind of way, but calmly, with composure and empathy, intellectually honest and also recognizing all the good that’s there. Then light comes through the cracks.

The youth group as a creative minority

The sociologist Peter Berger developed the idea of plausibility structures. It means that our worldview becomes plausible mainly through our social environment. Since we Christians are now a cognitive minority, the plausibility of our faith can’t simply be derived from society’s values.⁴ That gives Christian community, and so the youth group, new missional importance. Because that’s the place where faith becomes plausible. Walter Brueggemann writes:

“No one can enter another world (worldview) unless the alternative world is painted before their eyes splendidly, with great artistry, care and courage. The picture of an alternative script for their life invites the listener to step out of their previous context. … That’s the point where I realize that the way I live isn’t the only way I can live.”⁵ — Walter Brueggemann

If culture critique is the content side, the theoretical part where faith becomes plausible, then the creative minority is the practical part. Together they paint the vision of a life with Jesus and invite teens to ask themselves: What if I lived like that? The “creative minority” is, so to speak, the catechism come to life. It embodies the teaching of Jesus and so the beauty of the gospel. And that makes it a creative counterculture. Creative in the sense of alternative, inspiring and life-giving, because it shows a way of living that gives life and heals.

The professor of religion James Hunter distinguishes three strategies Western Christians have used in recent decades:⁶

  1. Fighting back against secular culture and trying to dominate it (culture war)
  2. Striving for purity and withdrawing from society completely
  3. Making compromises with the culture and fitting in

The creative minority manages to bring two things together that the other strategies couldn’t.

First: it manages to connect with society, because it doesn’t withdraw from the world but lives in it and takes part in it intentionally and actively.

Second: it manages to challenge society, because it lives out an alternative worldview. When we connect with society and challenge it at the same time, we create the possibility for non-Christians to reach the point where they ask themselves: “Isn’t this actually the better way to live and to understand the world?”

The Australian pastor Mark Sayers says that Christians, “as a creative minority, can be a healing presence in society, because they aren’t distorted by society’s idols.”⁷ Secular society can’t solve the problems it has created through its way of life on its own, because the problems are rooted in the system itself.

The creative minority shows the alternative:

It’s a community full of loving, close relationships in a society full of individualism and tribalism.

It’s a community full of rest and peace in a society full of exhaustion.

It’s a community full of holiness in a society full of moral relativism.

It’s a community full of hope in a society full of uncertainty.

“As a creative minority, Christians can be a healing presence in society, because they aren’t distorted by society’s idols.” — Mark Sayers

Even if you’d probably never say it so directly or out loud, it still seems to be a paradigm in many circles: as soon as a church has a fog machine and flashing lights with a perfect stage show, revival will come. Recently I talked with a pastor who leads a large, hip church and followed exactly this paradigm. The church was successful in terms of numbers, too.

But he realized that this isn’t what Generation Z needs, and above all that it doesn’t bind them to Jesus in the long term. They started holding worship nights with just a guitar and time for silence and prayer. And he noticed how intensely the teens soaked it up. How much they longed for this simple encounter with the holy, the sacred. We live in a world with an overdose of “hip,” and as churches we try to be just as hip and somehow hope this will make us relevant. Yet it’s precisely the sacred, the holy, the otherness that creates real relevance. And the creative minority is a living example of this otherness.

Happy in digital exile

Resilient teens live free in exile, because they neither need the culture’s approval nor have to demonize the culture to feel better about themselves. They live confidently, lovingly and hopefully, because they understand where the cracks in the secular narrative are, and because, emotionally and socially, through digital content and as part of a creative minority, they have the plausibility structures they need for their faith. That makes them, as individuals and as a group, strong witnesses in a complex world.

The quotes from Walter Brueggemann and Mark Sayers are rendered from the German, not verbatim.

Notes

  1. See David Kinnaman and Mark Matlock, Faith for Exiles (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 2019).
  2. Postbank youth digital study 2021 (in German): postbank.de.
  3. See Tim Keller, How to Reach the West Again (New York: Redeemer City to City, 2020), pp. 38ff.
  4. See Peter L. Berger and Thomas Luckmann, The Social Construction of Reality.
  5. Walter Brueggemann, The Word Militant: Preaching a Decentering Word (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2010), p. 33.
  6. Keller, How to Reach the West Again, p. 46.
  7. Mike Gore (@_mikegore), “Church Conversations: The Culturally Relevant Church,” Instagram, August 19, 2021: instagram.com.