Candlelight. An Ed Sheeran song in the background. My crush is sitting across from me. Their eyes are shining with expectation. The moment is perfect. My feelings are ready to come out. But what do I say now? “I love you”? “Can you imagine being in a relationship with me”? “I’d be really happy if we got together”? In this moment everything sounds wrong. And what if I get turned down and laughed at? Is it my hair or my shirt? Won’t we lose the amazing friendship we have?

These may be just a few of the thoughts that run through your head in a moment like this. Even before any questions about sex before marriage, homosexuality or sexual positions, the questions I tend to hear in youth groups are these:

  • Does my partner have to be a Christian?
  • When am I ready for a relationship?
  • Are parents allowed to forbid a relationship?
  • How do I know if my crush likes me too?
  • How early can you find your true love?
  • At church the other day he waved at me in a really obvious way, and he acts strangely when I’m around. He always hugs me when we say goodbye. Does that mean anything?

Compared with a long-haul flight, teenagers’ interest in everything to do with relationships seems to lie less with the destination or the comfort during the flight, and more with carefully choosing the airline, the words of greeting to the flight crew at boarding and the safest way to behave at takeoff. More exciting than shaping a relationship or aiming for marriage are

  • choosing “the right one,”
  • reading your crush’s signals correctly and
  • getting over the inner hurdles to starting a relationship.

Since most teenage relationships begin around age 16¹, these questions make sense. But by far the most common question is this one:

Why is this so complicated?

A young couple sits close together on a couch and takes a selfie with a phone

Even the writer of Proverbs 30:19 says: three things amaze me (the way of an eagle in flight, the way a snake moves, the way a ship finds its course on the open sea), but the way of love between a man and a woman is beyond me. Over thousands of years, it seems more about love has stayed hidden than we can ever know.

In our hearts we feel a force that pulls us toward other people like a magnet and gets stronger and stronger the closer someone comes to us. We humans were created to need relationship, by HIM whose very nature is relationship. Our soul is shaped like HIS. HE, who himself longs for a close relationship with us, created this magnet of longing in us, so that we look for completion in someone else. What I long for most, I can’t give myself. In looking for a partner, teenagers probably feel this longing so concretely for the first time in their lives, and with the ability to reflect on what’s going on inside and outside of them.

Why can this wonderful, longing force toward relationship also be experienced as painful? Rejection, feelings that aren’t returned, insecurity, being embarrassed in front of your peers, getting together and breaking up, heartbreak, jealousy and so on are just a few examples. Why doesn’t God show me my great love with total clarity, and show me to my great love? Wouldn’t that make so many things simpler? As tempting as that idea sounds, it misses two crucial points:

#1 Without tension, no finding a partner

Two teenagers on a pink couch in a living room, one reading a book, the other looking at a phone

Tension is built into creation: day and night, summer and winter, life and death, even down into the smallest atom (plus and minus). Without loss there’s no gain: I have to set options aside to have others at all. So you have to say “no” to all the women in the world to live a real, faithful, deep relationship with the one woman.

“If you want to, you can have it all” is the lie of a consumer-driven economic system, and it falls apart at the latest when it meets the reality of relationships.

Without the risk of getting hurt by a no, there’s no chance of a relationship getting started. Without vulnerability, no love. Removing this tension robs finding a partner of what it is.

#2 Looking for a partner boosts development

Looking for a partner can be an important building block in developing your own identity. The very fact that puberty often awakens interest in romantic relationships points to this: the body seems to lead the mind on purpose to places where it risks getting hurt, because it expects the greatest opportunities for growth there.

Finding a partner serves the development of identity. Being considerate of and responsible for someone besides myself helps me mature.

The developmental psychologist Klaus Hurrelmann describes it like this: identity is the process of bringing the “inner” and the “outer” into harmony. We develop in the ways our inner self makes possible. At the same time, we want to fit into our outer surroundings and belong. Hardly any process demands as much self-confidence (inner) and communication skill (outer) as looking for a partner. Every attempt to “tell your crush” is already a success, because it has already set the process of identity development in motion. Whether the attempt succeeds or fails then only decides how motivated you’ll be to step into the ring again in the future, not whether development has happened or not. At the same time, rejection on the outside (“I don’t want to be your partner.”) can be interpreted as rejection of the inside (“You aren’t someone worth loving.”). Some negative attitudes toward relationships or marriage suggest there’s emotional scar tissue here.

Two young people ride bikes through the city, and a young woman looks back toward the camera
Every attempt to “tell your crush” is already a success, because it has already set the process of identity development in motion. Photo: Unsplash+

How can adults support teenagers in all these questions? What unspoken climate in families or churches encourages brave, mature, self-determined decisions in looking for a partner?

Good and bad climate conditions

Good climate conditionsBad climate conditions
New relationships are met with great joy and with different fitting offers to walk alongside or coach the couple. Couples feel seen, encouraged and supported along the way.Examples from the area of relationships and sexuality are often used to illustrate sin. This puts up inner warning signs that point more to the danger of falling than they spark anticipation of the view from the summit. A culture that quietly suspects young couples of being sexually “out of control” does harm.
Singles are kept in view, both in terms of space (offers, places to meet …) and in terms of content (sermon topics, personal stories). Both ways of life (singles and couples) are not supported because of their neediness, but given roles because of their strengths. What can only a single person offer couples and families? What can only couples and families offer singles?Marriage (prep) seminars, family ministry, kids’ programs, family retreats … The only focus in programs and all planning is on married couples, families and children. Singles constantly feel incomplete, because their way of life simply doesn’t come up, and they keep being shown, or having other couples parade in front of them without a second thought, what they are not or don’t have (yet). Being single as a biblical way of life doesn’t come up and is left out.
Alongside programs for men and women separately, as a safe space for conversation, interests that are classically associated with the other gender are also included and can be lived out without judgment.Gender stereotypes are emphasized and catered to with “men’s barbecue nights” and “men’s beer tastings” or “women’s craft afternoons” and “women’s spa evenings.” People who fall between these drawers of interests find no place and don’t feel like a real woman or a real man in the eyes of those around them.
Without exception, people pay attention to communicating in an ethical way. Small signs of gossip are lovingly addressed, and a culture of sincerity and honesty with yourself is strengthened. Weakness is answered with prayer, encouragement and support, and sensitive information is handled even more sensitively.Church and family are a space for gossip, where people talk at length about couples, sermons and also leadership decisions, sometimes in pious clothing “just for prayer.” Rumors, doubts and anything scandalous make the rounds quickly, without the people involved being present or decision-makers being able to explain themselves. People talk more “about” than “with.” In a culture like this, people talk a lot, but less honestly, because everyone is afraid of becoming the topic themselves. Showing weakness is a disadvantage.
God loves people who give cheerfully (2 Corinthians 9:7). Without bitterness, but with great joy, everyone brings what they have and trusts that the other person thinks the same way. Thinking that every gift must be paid back is countered by valuing the gifts received from God. Knowing that I’ve been given what I need brings great freedom in looking for a partner.A consumer attitude leads to a sense of entitlement and a need to keep the scales balanced toward those in charge, leaders or volunteers. I give money, help out or invest time and expect something equal in return from the people around me. These patterns of thinking also show up in looking for a partner: I expect the same beauty, the same investment of time, the same involvement from my partner as I bring, or at least something equal in return (for example, financial advantages instead of beauty).

So how do I tell my crush?

A young woman leans her head on a smiling young man’s shoulder on a bus

Ideally the same way I would say it to my partner 50 years from now. Nikolaus Franke described it like this in his seminar “Flirting as a Christian”: A good Christian flirt leaves the other person richer. That means I don’t state expectations or demands, but express how my crush enriches my life. “I love spending time with you. You inspire me. I feel like I can really make a difference after we’ve met. I like the sound of your voice. Your warmth and sensitivity make me feel at home.” Even if no relationship comes of it, the other person is a little richer in knowing who they are, what they’re worth and what they can make happen. And that means something.


¹ See BZgA (German Federal Centre for Health Education), data set “Youth Sexuality,” 2019 survey.

This article first appeared in the Weisses Kreuz magazine “Einander finden” (issue 93). More on the topic there (in German).