You’re standing in front of a burning house. You have a bucket of water in your hand, and behind you ten firefighters are asleep. Which way do you throw the water?
Admittedly, this example is a bit over the top. But it still describes a challenge in youth evangelism very well:
We research and ask what interests teenagers, what makes them tick and how to reach them for Jesus. And yet the biggest specialists and experts are already sitting in our churches and youth groups. They’re the teens themselves who already live with Jesus. They don’t just have an outside perspective; they’re part of this generation themselves.
And that’s not all. Core values of Gen Z are authenticity, personal relevance, experiencing things for themselves and inspiring personalities. This also suggests that successful evangelism doesn’t necessarily happen through gifted speakers, beautifully designed Insta posts or impressive events. Instead, it’s ordinary people who can talk about their living faith credibly and authentically, but also understandably and approachably.
But how can we equip teens to use this potential and pass on their faith? One good way to do this intensively is “testify,” a course that equips young people to talk about Jesus in their everyday lives. That’s why this course is also part of the groundwork for truestory.
But even though a course like this is well suited for training, challenging and going deeper, personal evangelism is more than an activity you carry out or a program you work through. If evangelism is to become a lifestyle, part of the DNA, then the culture lived out in a youth ministry is decisive. It often shapes people much more, and more lastingly, than spoken words and content.
Here are five practical ideas that can help you shape a culture like this in your youth ministry.
#1 Don’t put them under (performance) pressure
Nothing gets in the way of honestly and openly raving about Jesus more than the feeling that you have to. It gets even worse when you feel you have to do something but can’t. This tension can’t always be fully resolved, so to some extent you have to live with it. But it’s still important to establish one principle from the start:
Evangelism is always missio Dei.
It isn’t that we have to do something for God; he does it together with us. We aren’t salespeople paid on commission who have to meet a quota. We’re witnesses who openly and honestly speak up for Jesus and the gospel, point to him and invite people to him. We want to do that well, thoughtfully and reflectively, but what ultimately happens in people’s hearts is God’s business. So first of all, I can relax.

I don’t have to talk anyone into anything, and I can’t, let alone force anything on them. I don’t have to sugarcoat anything or make anything up either. I simply talk about what I experience and have recognized as true. Instead of falling into performance pressure, we can get involved in God and his mission and watch with anticipation what he has in store for us. That takes the pressure off and sets us free.
I don’t have to start preaching right away; I can listen and ask questions first, but at the decisive moment I can also talk about Jesus and his gospel boldly and confidently. Even if not every word is theologically polished yet.
Passing this attitude on to teens and modeling it is much more effective than putting on pressure with an underlying “Shouldn’t we all actually …”
#2 Make room to talk openly about experiences
Starting youth group with a round of “What did you experience with Jesus this week?”, for example, can feel very unfamiliar at first. I often had to make a real effort to have at least something to share myself. But over time, more people shared. The questions “What have I even experienced with Jesus?” or “Why don’t I experience anything with him?” became more and more present in everyday life, and so they became a challenge too. “Someone on the bus looked stressed, so I spontaneously prayed for her silently.” “Someone asked me what I’m doing tonight. I got to tell them briefly that I believe in God and go to a youth group here.” “Yesterday I was laughed at because I believe in God, and I just didn’t know what to say.” That creates openness, makes room for honest questions and removes the first hurdle right away: talking itself.
If we don’t talk openly and honestly about our faith among ourselves, why would we do it in everyday life?
No story is too small or too unimportant.
And working out the words in a safe setting, where I won’t be laughed at or torn apart right away, creates security and builds confidence.
#3 Shape language people understand
“Please replace and tamp down your divots, rake the bunkers and repair ball marks where necessary.” For someone who knows golf well, this sentence is surely easy to understand and self-explanatory. For outsiders, though, it’s just confusing gibberish, or simply misleading, because the terms can mean different things. Among Christians there are lots of these words too. Even if we may not notice right away. Many people simply don’t know what we mean by “worship, sin, grace, prayer” or “fellowship,” to name just the tip of the iceberg. Even seemingly clear terms like “church,” “Jesus” or “God” often mean something completely different to outsiders than we tend to assume in a Christian context. In that case, our communication with outsiders fails right at the start. Then we aren’t rejected because of what we say, but simply misunderstood.
That’s why a basic principle in every form of evangelism is to find and shape language people understand. You can keep this in mind as early as preparing talks and devotionals, when leading and in prayers.
Just keep asking yourself: Do only my teens understand this, among themselves, or could they tell it to their friends exactly like this?

“Because Jesus simply takes away everything that stands between me and God and has made sure there’s an undisturbed relationship between the two of us, I can talk with him completely freely” just sounds very different from “Because Jesus forgave my sin and so redeemed me, I can come to him in prayer at any time.”
It’s very helpful, and fun too, to create a kind of vocabulary notebook together with your youth group, where you collect paraphrases or replacement words for religious terms. It can really help to address prejudices within the group too, clear up misunderstandings and, above all, learn from the teens themselves.
Empty phrases keep people dependent; really having understood something helps them put it into words.
#4 Find simple ways to explain the gospel
“I’ve been a leader here for two years, but nobody has ever explained to me why exactly that cross is hanging up front.” This encounter may have been extreme, but it wasn’t a one-off. Many people find it hard to explain what exactly the gospel, the core message of the Christian faith, is. Sure, there are different theological views and fine points. But if I had to break it down to one sentence, I’d do it like this: through Jesus it’s possible again to live in community with God.
In New Testament times, “gospel” was a well-known, commonly used word. Today it’s a foreign word whose meaning isn’t automatically clear or can get mixed up with other meanings. That makes it all the more important for us to fill the term with content again and again. The danger that teens just repeat empty phrases is especially big here.
If they haven’t understood what the terms mean themselves, they can’t translate them into their lives and their own words either.
Then it’s understandable when many teens ask themselves: “What exactly do we believe here? Why do we meet here?” To respond to these questions, it helps a lot to repeat even seemingly obvious basics again and again and explain them in a way people understand.

Stories, illustrations and practical examples work especially well for this. Of course every comparison falls short, and finding examples that aren’t just nice to tell but also theologically sound is a challenge. But it’s better for individual aspects to be really understood than for teens to be left with nothing but a big question mark in their heads at the end. And how are you supposed to pass on what you haven’t understood yourself?
A simple but understandable example of the gospel could look something like this:
Our life and Jesus are a bit like a lamp with a plug. This lamp is really well made and well designed. But it was also designed to be connected to electricity. Only then does it fulfill its purpose.
Now, we know that electricity, that is, electrons, are everywhere in the world, in every object. But the problem is that we can’t just pour a bottle of electricity over the lamp to make it light up again.
Instead, we need a proper access point to connect the lamp to electricity. And that access point is an outlet. When I plug the lamp in there, it gets power and can light up. It’s the same with God and people.
We humans were made by God. But we were made to be connected to him and to live in a relationship with him. That’s what we’re here for. Now, I know God is everywhere. He’s in nature, and maybe I can sometimes even feel him, but I still need an access point through which I’m fully connected to God and live together with him. And that access point is Jesus. In Jesus, God came to us humans, into our world and down to our level. He went unimaginably far: he experienced exclusion, was tortured and even died. But he didn’t stay dead; he defeated death. So he made a kind of connection to God through which, if we hold on to him, we can live together with God again. That’s why Jesus is like an outlet for us. And when I connect fully with Jesus and say: “I want to live with you!”, then I’m filled with God and live in community with him again. Then I live again for what I was made for. Just like this lamp can now light up again. This isn’t just dead theory; it also has very real effects on my life. These can look very different. For example, we can learn to accept ourselves, because God accepts us as we are. Because God says “yes” to us, we can handle it better when others reject us, and we can even love people we don’t like. We experience that we aren’t alone in our everyday lives, but that God gives us his strength. So we can endure challenging situations and even forgive people who have hurt us. God gives us a calling, he changes us, gives us healing and frees us from things that weigh us down.
In short: through Jesus I’m connected with God again. And that doesn’t just make my life bright again; it also makes me a light in this world.
#5 Use concrete activities
Theory is all well and good, but in the end it’s practice that really shapes people. It can be fun and bring a whole new drive to youth ministry when activities aren’t just focused inward, but everyone actually sets out to be a witness for Jesus. When activities like this are a regular, normal part of your youth ministry, they also become part of the culture and the DNA.
Whether it’s a prepared service at the nearest senior home, handing out care packages to people experiencing homelessness or, for the really brave, a prayer walk downtown, where you pray silently for people or even talk to some of them. Jumping into ice-cold water isn’t always helpful, though. What fits your group? What’s challenging but not overwhelming? Where can your teens definitely have positive experiences? Maybe they have an idea themselves. And then just get out of the church building!
The only thing that achieves nothing is doing nothing.
