A full room one week and only a handful of teenagers the next. Someone from the area who has never been to church shows up, and it happens to be the night the talk is about tithing. If you lead a youth group, you know moments like these. Mark Tittley, a pastor in Johannesburg, South Africa, wrote down the questions that kept frustrating him during twenty years in youth ministry. The list is short, and you’ll probably recognize most of it.
He begins with attendance that rises and falls with whatever is on the program, and with visitors who land in a session that was never meant for them. Then come the bigger questions. Should youth ministry go to where teenagers are, or wait for them to come? Jesus did both: he invited people to come to him, and he sent his followers out. What about the “back door”? When Tittley listed every young person who had visited his group in a year, he realized it should have been twice or three times as big. Why do so many drop out when they move up to the next age group, and why do ministries for children, teenagers and young adults so often run as if the others didn’t exist?
The last points will sound familiar too: too many areas to keep in view at once, the urge to cancel every program and just hang out with young people, and complaints from one side that the program is too spiritual and from the other that it doesn’t help them grow.
Tittley doesn’t stop at the questions. At the end he outlines the strategy he found: build the ministry of each age group around different levels of spiritual commitment, and coordinate those levels across all ages, from preschoolers to young adults. That is the core of his Commitment Level Model, which he explains on other pages of his site. Read the list with your team and ask which of these frustrations is yours right now.
More from Pulse
- What Relational Youth Leaders Do Differently
- 4 Common Mistakes in Youth Ministry
- How Can We Build an Intergenerational Church? 9 Tips
- Survival Guide for Your Youth Ministry
This article by Mark Tittley first appeared on his website, ymresourcer.com. Pulse published a German version in October 2025 (in German).
