📍
What is truestory? truestory is a youth evangelism outreach by proChrist: Over several evenings, the truestory Nights, evangelists talk about Jesus and invite teens to get to know him.

What is this post? One of the ready-made youth night outlines from the truestory evangelist handbook that the evangelists use to prepare. It gives you everything for a complete evening on one theme and Bible passage: the world teens live in, background on the text, possible questions, a worked-out talk outline for both formats, “Dialogue” and “Stage,” and concrete ideas for how teens can respond.

How you can use it: as a ready-to-use template for your own evangelistic evening or youth night, which you can adapt freely to your group.

More about truestory and its material: truestory.eu (in German)

truestory Night 00 · John 20:24-29

The listeners’ perspective

Teens look at their smartphones with doubt. Is that a real picture showing up on Insta? Did this TikTok video really happen like that? Thanks to AI, it’s no great feat anymore to make altered images look real.

Teens doubt politics. Who actually keeps their promises? Which person, which party can I trust to stand up after the election for what I voted for? Teens doubt that they can make a difference. Can I change anything in this world? Or does it ultimately not matter how much trash I produce or how many long-distance trips I take? Teens doubt their own worth. Am I valuable? Am I important to anyone? Do I have real, deep friendships? Teens doubt faith. Does faith do anything? Does Jesus really exist, and does he step in? Can I really feel and experience Jesus in everyday life?

Doubting is exhausting. Teens don’t know what to believe and how to decide. They need good judgment, trust and faith. Doubt looks for truth, for certainty and clarity, so that it can make good decisions. But who can teens turn to? Who helps them out of their doubts?

The truestory Nights are meant to be a place where teens can go with their doubts. The volunteers have prepared for the truestory Nights for weeks. They have put time and energy into the preparations. And then, shortly before the start, doubts come after all. Why should I invite people to this event? If I invite people, what does that say about me? Will it be embarrassing? Is it worth the effort? Will anyone (new) even come? I keep doubting my own faith. Can I still serve here?

Lotte: I’m totally sold on the truestory idea, because here you can get your questions out and find answers to your doubts. But I’m worried that my friend won’t really give it a chance.
Marco: I wonder if I’m a bad Christian or a bad volunteer because I still have so many questions about faith myself.

The gospel and the theme

With Jesus, doubting is clearly allowed. He meets doubt, invites us to investigate critically and gives certainty. That’s exactly what should happen at truestory. Doubts are taken seriously; we “feel” them and get to the bottom of them. We have good answers to many questions, and for the rest we expect Jesus to make himself known in a way people can experience, like he did with Thomas back then. Jesus isn’t afraid of questions or of doubts. In all the Gospels there is no sneaky question and no open doubt that he doesn’t respond to in the right way. He is who he is, and no interrogation changes that. Jesus is the heart of truestory. It’s an event that creates space to meet HIM. Jesus isn’t embarrassing. What he says is the truth. He can touch and change people. Because Jesus is true and his power is real, we don’t need to be afraid of doubts. Neither our own nor those of the people we want to reach. God’s Spirit can give clarity.

At truestory we open up space for questions and doubts. It’s a chance to get to the bottom of faith once more. Teens put the Christian worldview to the test and ask themselves whether it might be the truth. They want to know whether faith is relevant and has the power to make a difference in this world and in my life. We want to create a safe space where doubting is allowed and where we can look for answers together. If we start from the fact that Jesus is the truth, difficult questions can at most show the limits of what we can explain. Our faith stays firm, because Jesus is the foundation.

Where we reach the limits of our explanations, we pray that Jesus meets the doubters and gives them certainty, like he did with Thomas back then. WE don’t have to convince anyone. We tell people about Jesus, we lead people to him, and he takes care of the rest.

Background to the text

The story of Thomas shows that at first there were doubts about the resurrection even in the closest circle of disciples. In the end, no uncertainty or doubt remains. Jesus convinces.

“We have seen the Lord” is the short formula for the experience of an appearance. “A week later” means the following Sunday. Sunday is hinted at as the Christian day of celebration. Whether Thomas touched the wounds remains open. He answers Jesus with a confession that holds nothing back. Thomas won’t believe without tangible proof. Jesus meets that need. Faith that at its core needs outward seeing remains incomplete. Still, it isn’t looked down on, because in the end Thomas really understands who Jesus is. Jesus meets Thomas where he is.

The story of Thomas is the closing story of the Gospel of John (chapter 21 is considered an epilogue). John has two purposes with it. First, he wants to state clearly who Christ is: Jesus is God. In what he does and in who he is, Jesus is one with the Father (see John 14:9). Thomas now recognizes Jesus the way he wants to be and should be seen. Second, John wants to appeal to us, the church that would come later: Jesus won’t appear to us as the risen one in a way we can touch. Even so, we are to believe. Jesus gives special honor to faith that rests on the testimony of the disciples and on the Word.

The story has two threads. The first is faith that Jesus really rose from the dead. Thomas resists believing. Jesus calls him to believe. Thomas confesses. Those who believe are called blessed. The second thread is about seeing as a condition for faith. Thomas wants to see and check whether what the other disciples are telling him is true. Jesus takes this desire seriously and meets it.

What it means in real life

Even in Jesus’ closest circle there was someone who needed something tangible. It wasn’t enough for him just to hear the message. Teens long for tangible evidence. They want to be convinced because the case holds up. They don’t want to stay in uncertainty; they want to experience faith.

The Bible passage says: Actually, this shouldn’t be necessary. The gospel and the testimony of people should speak for themselves. That should be enough to believe that Jesus exists and that he is God; in short, that faith has a firm foundation.

At the same time, we see in the text how Jesus cares for Thomas like a pastor. He comes into the room and turns to Thomas right away. He gives Thomas the proof he longs for. Jesus doesn’t scold him. He doesn’t say: “I’m disappointed. How can you still doubt after all this time?” Thomas doesn’t have to explain himself. Jesus knows his heart. He knows that this is important for Thomas right now, so that he can stay with him. He gives him the certainty he needs. The Bible passage invites us to get clear about our own doubts. What do I need to gain certainty? For truestory, that means: As with Thomas, Jesus also knows the hearts of the teens who come. He knows what doubts they’re wrestling with. He knows what it takes to give them certainty. He knows the conditions that lead from unbelief to faith.

Lotte: I want to be brave and invite my friend. If she can’t come to faith here, then where? She loves conversation and discussion.
Marco: I think it’s cool that a disciple of Jesus had doubts like that. If Jesus can use Thomas, maybe he can use me too.

Key thought

Jesus meets doubt and the doubter, and he gives certainty.


Dialogue and stage outlines

Dialogue

Introducing the text

Today I brought something that I assume really everyone knows and has probably used before. Who has ever seen one of these? (Show a bug viewer, a magnifying cup.) And who has ever looked at something more closely through one? These bug viewers are pretty brilliant, because you can, for example, take a close look at living creatures without worrying that they’ll crawl off and disappear while you’re watching them. With insects, you can look closely at the wings, the antennae, the shell or the legs. Can I find the ears on the grasshopper’s belly? Which ant do I actually have here: a male or the queen? …

I have to admit, I’m not a big fan of insects and reptiles. Still, I find it incredibly interesting to look at them closely. Behind glass, even I can handle it. Those amazing eyes, the way the wings are built, all the hairs on the legs … It’s really worth looking closely and checking what you learn in biology class. And I’ve found that I’m not the only one who likes to take a thorough look. Today I want to introduce you to a person from the Bible who also likes to play it safe.

Thomas is one of Jesus’ twelve disciples. He hears that Jesus is alive again after being crucified. And doubts come up.

Possible questions

  • Where was Thomas the last time Jesus was there?
  • On what day did Jesus come back?
  • Why had the disciples locked the doors?
  • If Thomas was one of the twelve disciples, was he really an unbeliever?
  • Why does Thomas say, “My Lord and my God”?
  • Why does Jesus “scold” Thomas? Isn’t that unfair? After all, the others all saw Jesus for themselves too.
  • Am I not allowed to doubt Jesus or my faith?
  • Can I (also) ask Jesus for “proof” that he exists?
  • Why doesn’t Jesus prove himself to me?
  • Why are those who don’t see Jesus and still believe happy?

Ideas for the closing talk

“I want to. I want to see. I want to feel.” Thomas wants to convince himself. Clear away every doubt. In my view, there are 2 ways to respond to doubt.

One way: I say, “When in doubt, go with the doubt.” I stay in uncertainty, and honestly I feel quite comfortable there. A good place for people who don’t like making decisions. But also a place where I’m stuck. In the worst case, my doubts paralyze me. If I don’t know whether I can trust my friend, I’ll never tell her my secrets. Our relationship will never go deeper.

The other way: I use the chance to dig deeper. I WANT to make a decision. I WANT to move forward. That’s exactly what Thomas chooses. He wants to know whether this thing about the resurrection is really true.

The resurrection of Jesus is so unbelievable that doubts can come up really fast. Imagine Thomas hadn’t seen Jesus himself, and later someone asks him: “Hey, are you sure Jesus really rose from the dead? I mean, you were one of his best friends. Why didn’t he say goodbye to you in person? Don’t you think that’s weird?” And suddenly doubt starts gnawing at Thomas: “Well, it is weird. The others just told me, and I believed them. But whether it’s really true …”

Thomas saw Jesus after the resurrection. He wasn’t just told about it. It wasn’t an optical illusion either. Jesus was there. No one will take that experience away from him. No one will be able to convince him of anything else. And the craziest part: Jesus came to him on his own initiative. Jesus invites Thomas to feel and to check. Thomas needed this proof. Jesus knew that. He met the doubt.

The teens who come to our truestory Nights this week are searching. Jesus has already walked part of the way with them, or they wouldn’t be here. They WANT to. They want to be moved by Jesus. They have a longing that wants to be satisfied. At the very least they have questions they want answers to. Or they’ve gotten curious and want to see what Jesus is all about. Jesus knows their wishes and their doubts, and he knows what the teens need. That’s why you can go into this week full of confidence. God is there. The Holy Spirit will use you to reach teens. I wish you this expectation and this open heart for truestory.

God will use you to take away teens’ doubts. The Holy Spirit will fill you and show you what to say or do. Maybe you’ll just get a sense of whom to talk to or whom to play foosball with.

Stage

Ideas for illustration

  • While you talk about the first way to respond to doubt, you can stand on a balance board.
  • Snacks for the night: In German-speaking countries there is a brand of chips and popcorn called “Zweifel,” which means “doubt.” Maybe you can find a similar play on words where you live.
  • A song about doubt (the German original suggests Max Giesinger’s “Deine Zweifel,” “Your Doubts”): Do they stay, like in the song, or can I hand them over?
  • Exercises with balance boards: With doubts you’re constantly wobbling, and that’s exhausting.
  • Play giant Jenga as a tower of doubt.
  • Pass on a doubt wall as prayer requests to a prayer team that prays for truestory during the week.

Possible talk outline

Do you sometimes feel like you’ve missed out on something too? There was the party of the year, and for weeks everyone is talking about stories that happened there, and you … you weren’t there.

It must have been like that for Thomas, only much more intense. Because it wasn’t just about some embarrassing stunts he missed. His friends saw a dead man. And now they want to make him believe that they saw their dead friend alive. That’s wild, just imagine it. Maybe Thomas thinks, “Okay, wild story.” Maybe he also thinks it’s pretty sick to mess with him like that so soon after Jesus died. But his friends won’t stop with the nonsense. They mean it seriously. But Thomas isn’t going to fall for it. If he’s seriously supposed to believe this, then he has to see it.

Do you know that feeling? The story is so unbelievable that you really can’t believe it. If you told me that beaming objects or people is possible now, I’d also say: I have to see it before I believe it. In my mind, it’s just impossible. I can’t explain it. (Apparently Chinese scientists have already managed to beam photons over 400 km.)

Thomas doubts. And I think that’s completely normal. After all, the other disciples (except one) also saw Jesus first before they believed. When I doubt something, it’s also a chance to dig deeper. I can get to the bottom of it. Maybe I also have to wrestle for an answer. And that makes me grow. When I wrestle with issues, it strengthens my character and how I form my opinions. For example, I no longer believe out of tradition, just because that’s how I grew up. I’ve worked through it myself. I’ve questioned my faith, found answers, but also new questions. My faith is developing and becoming steady. Not every hardship, not every crisis throws me off track anymore, because I’ve gathered experience. My faith has been tested in real life. Thankfully we’re not on our own either. It’s important that we support each other when we doubt. We can help each other get out of it. In a community it’s unlikely that everyone doubts at the same time, let alone about the same thing. While I’m finding it hard to believe right now, my friend might be totally “on fire.”

In our story, Jesus himself meets Thomas. He comes in, turns to him right away and says: “Look,” “Feel,” “See for yourself.” Faith in Jesus can bear weight; it has reasons. It doesn’t just have to be believed. It can be experienced. That’s why Jesus came to the disciples that evening. It matters to him that even the last of his disciples can believe it. With Jesus, doubting is allowed. He doesn’t shrug it off. He doesn’t say: “Too bad for Thomas. If he doesn’t want to believe, fine, I’ll do without him.” Jesus calls those happy who don’t need this confirmation. People who are so gripped by his word and the testimony of the disciples that they develop a deep faith. And still he doesn’t look down on Thomas’s faith. Jesus makes sure Thomas can be certain. It matters to him that Thomas believes. And it’s the same with you. Jesus invites Thomas to feel and to check, and he also invites you to investigate your specific questions. How strong is this God, to whom you matter so much that he responds to your needs? God doesn’t run a fixed program where whoever manages to keep up gets to believe and everyone else is left behind. Jesus wants to win you. I exist. I am with you. I’ll carry you through. You are not alone. Believe in me. And if you’re looking for him but find it hard to believe, he will meet you in a way you understand.

The evangelistic invitation

I hope you’ll go to Jesus with your doubts yourself. You can simply pray, talk with him:

“Jesus, there’s so much going on in my life right now, and somehow I’ve lost you in the chaos. I can’t believe anymore that you’re alive and that you step in. I’m groping in the dark, looking for something to hold on to. I WANT to believe in you. Meet me. Let me recognize you the way Thomas recognized you.”
“Jesus, I want so much for people to get to know you. But if I’m honest, I don’t believe that new teens will come. Surprise me and show me your greatness again, God.”
“Jesus, the teens have questions, and I don’t know how to handle them. I still understand so little about you and about the Bible myself. I have so few answers. Meet me in my own doubts this week, and help me to be a witness for you in spite of my doubts.”

God doesn’t leave you alone with your doubts. Say them out loud in prayer. Lay them at his feet and trust that he will meet them. HOW he does that is his business. Be sure: There is an answer.

In all the doubts and questions of my life, I am completely certain that God exists. He is there. He is bigger than my problems. And because he exists and because what the Bible says is true, I don’t need to be afraid. He will make it right. This certainty in faith gives my life such a firm hold that I can handle the wobbling in other areas of life, whether plans for the future, relationship stress …

At the end of his doubting, Thomas makes a confession. He is sure that it is Jesus, and through it he gets a glimpse of God’s power. Thomas trusts Jesus and entrusts his life to him. And that’s what I want to invite you to as well: to search, to find and to trust.

Response ideas

Thomas needed something tangible. Teens can write their doubts on a piece of paper, fold it and then nail it to a wooden cross with a hammer and nail. After the evening, the organizers must dispose of the doubts without reading them (shred or burn them).

As a contrast to the doubts that make teens unsure, they can take home stones as a sign of firm faith.