> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://thepulse.org/en/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Youth Group Session “Why Does God Allow Suffering?”
- URL: https://thepulse.org/en/why-does-god-allow-suffering/
- Published: 2024-01-17T05:00:09.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-15T19:27:30.000Z
- Description: How can there be a good God when we see so much suffering and injustice in the world? A youth group session with a worksheet, real-life stories, discussion questions and creative stations to help teenagers wrestle honestly and personally with the question.
- Author: Esther Penner
- Tags: Lessons, #age-teens, #topic-suffering, #lessons-bible-topic, #lessons-duration-long, #lessons-method-experiential, #lessons-method-icebreaker, #lessons-setting-plenary, #lessons-setting-small-group, #target-educators, #target-leaders, #context-youth-night, #context-small-group, #context-school, #translation-pending

## Youth Group Session “Why Does God Allow Suffering?”

The elements below give you different ways to explore the topic of suffering. It’s up to you whether you use all of them or just one. They’re tools for you: you decide how to use them. What matters:

- Be flexible and adapt the activities to your group’s dynamics.
- Make sure all the teenagers are included and feel comfortable.
- Be sensitive to emotional reactions, especially when things get personal.

*See also:* [Lessons](https://thepulse.org/en/lessons/)

## Icebreaker “Suffering in pictures”

⏱ 10 minutes

👉

Show pictures and headlines from news articles. Look for pictures and headlines in current news and choose the way of presenting them that fits your group:  
\- Print them out and lay them in the middle of the circle where everyone can see them.  
\- Print them out and hang them on the walls so the teenagers can walk around the room and look at them.  
\- Show them large on a screen or monitor so everyone can see them.

Today we’re taking on the question: “Why does God allow suffering?” Or: “How can there be a good God when we see so much suffering and injustice in the world?”

Here in this room (in front of you or on the screen) you can see pictures and headlines from news articles. Take some time to look at them.

❓

****When you look at these pictures, what thoughts or feelings come up in you?**

❓

****Which suffering do you think is caused by people (through wrongdoing or failure)?** (accidents, hunger, war, murder)

❓

****Which suffering do you think is more likely not caused by people?** (illness, natural disasters, victims of war and accidents)

❓

****What suffering can’t be seen in the pictures, but is real (you’ve experienced it yourself, or people you know have)?** (Possible answers from the teenagers: depression, anxiety, abuse, etc.)

❓

****How do you feel when you see people suffering? How does that fit with your picture of God?**

❓

****What questions do you have about suffering?**

## Group work “Common arguments for why God allows suffering”

⏱ 15 minutes

❓

****If God loves us, why does he allow suffering and pain in the world?**

****Download: worksheets**  
Download the worksheets and print the arguments “Free will” and “Soul-making.” Make enough copies for your small groups.

[Download ](https://thepulse.org/en/content/files/2026/11/pulse-worksheet-free-will-soul-making-en-1.pdf) 

*Free for your work with young people. What you may do with it:* [Terms of use](https://thepulse.org/en/terms/)*.*

👉

Split the teenagers into small groups of 2 to 4 and have each group discuss one of the arguments, “Free will” or “Soul-making,” for 5 minutes. Then bring together the results from all the groups.

*See also:* Youth group session “[Free Will](https://thepulse.org/en/free-will-youth-group-session/#simulation-game-paper-sharpener-pencil)”

## Personal stories

⏱ 15 minutes

👉

Choose one of the people below and tell the teenagers their story. Then talk through the questions below with them.

****Max Sprenger**  
Max wakes up one morning with a terrible headache. The pressure is so strong that he can no longer speak. At the hospital, Max Sprenger is put into an induced coma right away. The diagnosis: a brain bleed (stroke). When the boy, just 14 years old, wakes up again, he faces the serious effects of the bleed: he can no longer speak, and he can barely feel his arms and legs. “It’s as if my body has fallen asleep,” he says, describing his condition. The doctors can’t find a specific cause for the bleed. But they expect it will take decades for him to regain his abilities. For Max Sprenger, it’s a shock. For the first few days, all he can do is cry. On the German talk show Talkwerk, he shared how he is doing today and what keeps him from losing hope of healing.

****Arne Kopfermann**  
Arne is at the wheel himself when his daughter is killed in a car accident. After a serious crash, Arne Kopfermann has to bury his own child. How do you go on living after a loss like that? When does the pain finally stop? “Not a day goes by that I don’t think of her,” the musician says, even years after his daughter’s death. Arne Kopfermann knows that grief never ends. It only changes. Not everyone around him is understanding; at times he even has to listen to absurd theories about the supposed reason for his suffering. On the German talk show Talkwerk, he shared how he managed to keep going anyway and not lose his faith.

****Marcy Nähring**  
Marcy leaves her home in the Caribbean to study in Europe, where she meets Jens and they start a family. When a tumor is found in one of their children, she falls into a crisis. Through the prayer of a pastor at the hospital, she finds her way back to God and promises to serve him if her son is saved. After their son’s successful surgery, Marcy and Jens grow deeper in their faith. Years later, Marcy feels called to go to Mozambique to help there. Tragically, Jens is murdered in Mozambique, and Marcy has to wrestle with the loss and with her anger at God.

****Lukas Harrison**  
As a child, Lukas was harassed by a neighbor, which led to anger, depression and thoughts of suicide. His father suffered a traumatic brain injury, which made their relationship harder. Lukas found comfort in the heavy metal and goth music scene and came into contact with alcohol and drugs early on. After he joined the Army and was stationed in Iraq, he rejected God because he believed God was cruel. Later he met Chiara, who had also drifted away from the church. When Chiara turned back to the church, Lukas went along with her, skeptical. Through going to church regularly and a silent retreat, Lukas finally found his way to God and was able to forgive his father. Today he is a teacher and serves at his church in Kentucky.

❓

****What thoughts or questions came up for you as you heard the story? What especially moved or surprised you?**

❓

****How do you think this person would have reacted if other people had given them one of the arguments you just discussed as the reason for their suffering? What might that have done to them?**

❓

****What would you say to someone who is going through a hard time right now, or how would you help them?**

📞

****If you’re having thoughts of suicide, or you’re worried about someone:** In the US, call or text ****988** or chat at [988lifeline.org](https://988lifeline.org/?ref=thepulse.org) (988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: free, confidential, 24/7). Outside the US, [findahelpline.com](https://findahelpline.com/?ref=thepulse.org) lists free, confidential helplines in your country. If someone is in immediate danger, call your local emergency number.

## Reflection stations

⏱ 20 minutes

👉

Prepare one or more of the stations and give the teenagers a chance to think, at their own pace, about different sides of suffering and faith. Make sure you create an atmosphere where they feel free to share their thoughts and feelings. Set out enough paper and pens at each station.

**Station 1: Personal experiences**

- **Activity:** Create a “feelings wall” where the teenagers can anonymously write down their personal experiences with suffering.
- **Reflection question:** How has personal suffering affected your faith or the way you see God?

**Station 2: Prayer wall**

- **Activity:** Set up a wall where teenagers can write prayers or hopes for people who are suffering.
- **Reflection question:** Who or what do you want to pray for today, and why?

**Station 3: Art and creativity**

- **Activity:** Provide materials for drawing, painting or other creative expression so the teenagers can show their thoughts and feelings about suffering.
- **Reflection question:** Paint a picture that expresses your feelings and thoughts about suffering and God’s role in it.

**Station 4: Biblical perspectives**

- **Activity:** Have the teenagers read [Psalm 22:1-24](https://www.bible.com/bible/111/PSA.22.1-24.NIV?ref=thepulse.org) and set out pens and slips of paper with reflection questions.
- **Reflection questions:** How does the psalmist deal with his suffering? How does he talk to God about it? How did he experience God in his suffering? How do you experience God in your suffering?

**Station 5: Wall of hope**

- **Activity:** Create a quiet area where teenagers can think about hope and comfort and maybe write their own statements of hope.
- **Reflection question:** Where do you find hope and comfort in times of suffering?

*See also:* Youth group session “[Prayer: When God Is Silent](https://thepulse.org/en/prayer-when-god-is-silent/)”

## Wrapping up

Today we took on the hard question “Why does God allow suffering?” and you probably noticed that there’s no simple or clear answer. Maybe you’re even going home today with more questions than you had at the start. Take a moment to write down all the questions you have about suffering, fold them up and drop them into the box I’m about to pass around.

👉

Give the teenagers time to write down their questions. Collect them so you can pick up some of them at your next meetings. Keep walking with the teenagers as they learn to live with the tension of not having a final answer to the question of suffering, and at the same time not to stand still, but to count on Jesus and bring their suffering to him in lament. We can trust him even when we don’t have all the answers, because he himself was willing to suffer in a cruel way to guarantee us a future without suffering.

Before we close in prayer, I want to encourage you. No one, not a single person, not you and not me, is alone in the suffering we go through. Jesus is with us in this suffering, and he is with us in this pain. We can trust him, and he understands one hundred percent what we feel and how we’re doing. He has experienced suffering himself. Jesus had to take the news that John the Baptist, one of the people closest to him, had been murdered ([Matthew 14:10-13](https://www.bible.com/bible/111/MAT.14.10-13.NIV?ref=thepulse.org)). Some of his closest friends betrayed him and turned away from him. And then Jesus was killed in a cruel way.

📖 Read [Isaiah 53:3-5](https://www.bible.com/bible/111/ISA.53.3-5.NIV?ref=thepulse.org) and [2 Corinthians 1:3-4](https://www.bible.com/bible/111/2CO.1.3-4.NIV?ref=thepulse.org)

🙏

Close in prayer.