> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://thepulse.org/en/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Have We Whittled the Gospel Down to a Stub?
- URL: https://thepulse.org/en/whittled-down-gospel/
- Published: 2023-01-26T15:40:50.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T08:15:42.000Z
- Description: The fear of losing the core of their own understanding of the gospel has driven many shortened versions of it to set themselves sharply apart from other movements. How do we get back to a whole understanding of the gospel?
- Author: Andreas »Boppi« Boppart
- Tags: Articles, #target-leaders, #target-parents, #topic-planning, #topic-faith-questions, #topic-evangelism, #translation-pending

When I was in school (yes, that was a long time ago, and no, I didn’t write on a slate anymore), there was a big pencil sharpener on the teacher’s desk right in front of me in math class. My friend from the back row (where the not-so-gifted math students sat) used that sharpener remarkably often during tests. As he admitted to me years later, he sometimes broke his pencil lead on purpose so he could go up to the sharpener. Then he’d sneak a peek at the answers. The longer the peeking went on, the shorter the pencil got.

### The triangle of shortening

Shortened versions like this often come about:

- out of the need to set yourself apart from an unhealthy movement,
- because you want to communicate the gospel even more concisely, or
- because you greatly exaggerate your favorite theologies.

In soteriology (the doctrine of salvation, of Christ’s saving work), for example, there are two well-known extremes:

On one side is a socially liberal shortening that tends to focus one-sidedly on structural change, justice, peace and caring for creation, but often loses sight of the need for personal repentance and faith in Jesus Christ.

On the other side is the tendency toward a traditional shortening that reduces salvation to the forgiveness of sin and eternal life alone and either generously neglects or even completely ignores all the other dimensions of salvation Christ won for us on the cross.

The fear of losing the core of their own understanding of the gospel has driven many of these shortened versions to set themselves sharply apart from other movements. So they sharpened their own conviction further and further.

It’s good to ask yourself which shortening you personally feel most at home with. Because being blind to our own blind spots only encourages us to keep whittling and sharpening away at the gospel like crazy, often with the very best intentions.

The result:

> The perfect pencil point is no good for writing anymore. Instead, it sometimes gives the person across from us a painful jab.

### Other tendencies to shorten the gospel

It’s our job to expose our own shortened versions and move back toward a whole understanding of the gospel. The whole gospel for the whole world, nothing less. Here I can only name a few shortened versions that are widespread:

**The kingdom of God**: You can relate it to something purely otherworldly. But Christ said it has already begun, in our midst, within us.

The kingdom of God is at least as much about this world as about the next, and that gives us a responsibility to shape the here and now.

**Salvation**: So often salvation and redemption are reduced to something subjective. We only think of it as “personal,” when it’s at least as social and global, even cosmic. In one of his first public speeches, in the synagogue in Nazareth, Jesus applies the prophecy from [Isaiah 61](https://www.bible.com/bible/111/ISA.61.NIV?ref=thepulse.org) to himself. With it he makes unmistakably clear that he has come to preach the gospel to the poor, to proclaim freedom to the prisoners and sight to the blind, to set the oppressed free and to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor. With this he was alluding to the Year of Jubilee, the fiftieth year in the cycle of the people of Israel. In that year, land was to return to its original owners, slaves were to be set free and debts were to be canceled.

In fact, through his life and death, Christ brought a comprehensive salvation for everyone who thirsts for life and meaning. This salvation goes beyond a purely personal dimension. It also wants to bring about social and global change, for example justice and equality for the oppressed, the disregarded, the poor and those who aren’t free. Jesus’ salvation relates to the whole spectrum of human longing. The forgiveness of our guilt is absolutely part of it. But it’s only one part of his tremendous saving work on the cross.

> “Jesus’ salvation speaks to the whole spectrum of human longing.”

![Many people cross a busy crosswalk in a city, seen from above](https://thepulse.org/en/content/images/2026/11/gruppe-von-menschen-ueberquert-die-strasse-mrj.jpeg)

If we understood and lived the gospel as a whole, it would give the Christian faith an enormous boost in attractiveness and credibility. (Illustrative photo) Photo: [Kaique Rocha](https://www.pexels.com/photo/people-walking-on-pedestrian-lane-during-daytime-109919/?ref=thepulse.org).

Grasping all the dimensions of this salvation would be a massive game changer for Christianity. If we understood and lived the gospel as a whole, it would give the Christian faith an enormous boost in attractiveness and credibility. But we can’t get around the work of theological thinking.

Let’s take “un-shortening” the word “sin” as an example. Often, when we talk about sin, it’s only about moral wrongdoing. But at its root, sin means missing the mark. The goal was God’s great, all-encompassing shalom (Hebrew for “peace”). Our network of relationships was meant to rest in this peace. Repentance, then, isn’t just naming my moral failures, and it isn’t just that famous prayer of commitment either (which I prayed myself, more than once, and it helped me and did me good, by the way!).

At its root, repentance is a change of mind, a rethinking, a paradigm shift. Repentance is turning to God, coming home. That’s why the altar call that Charles Finney made popular in the 19th century was much more holistic than the way it’s often lived out today.

> Those who responded to that call back then could right away sign a pledge to stand up against slavery from then on.

A real paradigm shift took place there. If repentance describes the process of turning around and turning toward God, we can boldly question whether people can really only turn to God by confessing sins. Maybe turning to God is repentance in itself, even when no feeling of guilt is involved yet. This matches what I observe: people today still reach out to God with longing and turn to him. But the prayer “Lord, forgive me my guilt!”, which in some practice has almost become a magical, glorified spell, is often left out.

Many Christians sense that the gospel in this shortened form somehow doesn’t quite take hold anymore, neither inside them nor in society. A time of upheaval is coming that can become a new beginning. We’re standing on the threshold of something new.

### The thing about shame

Our main narrative in recent decades has been shaped by the trio: sin, forgiveness, eternal life. This story isn’t wrong; it’s deeply rooted in the Bible. But it’s very shortened. In the last century, this aspect of the gospel worked perfectly. It could connect with people’s world because people were strongly shaped by guilt. They longed for someone to forgive them. And after two world wars, a form of hope in life after death that escapes from the world was understandable. Now sociologists observe that in recent years we’ve gone through massive social upheaval and change.

One main point is that we’ve changed from a culture strongly shaped by guilt to a culture shaped more by shaming and shame. And that changes everything.

> Values are no longer defined by absolute fixed points, but much more by belonging to a group.

“Authentic” becomes the new truth: a person can lie, cheat and live immorally, but “what matters is that they’re real and themselves!”

People no longer say: “I make mistakes,” but: “I am a mistake.” Social media fuels this development deeply. There, you’re constantly confronted with your friends’ nicely photoshopped shop-window world, which then runs into your own inner brokenness.

That’s why people are no longer primarily looking for a “forgiver,” but for someone who takes away their shame. They’re looking for someone who accepts them in their feelings of inferiority, in their “I’m not enough” thinking, and loves them unconditionally. Of course sin and forgiveness are still a reality; it’s just that this aspect of the gospel hardly connects with people’s lives anymore.

> “On the cross, Christ didn’t just save us from guilt; he set off a whole fireworks display of salvation.”

It reminds me of the Mars Climate Orbiter, a probe from the US space agency NASA. It cost 193 million US dollars to build and traveled for ten months to explore Mars. Unfortunately, two parties involved calculated with different systems: one in metric, the other in feet and inches.

Result: the probe burned up on entering the Martian atmosphere because neither the speed nor the angle of entry was right.

In the same way, our gospel, shortened to guilt and forgiveness, fizzles out when it hits the atmosphere of people burdened by shame. We calculate and think in different systems, and the Good News has no way to land on the “planet” and connect. For Christians, the result is that we’re at a loss for words, and we can only fix this by setting out on the journey again ourselves and asking the wonderfully healing question:

> What, for heaven’s sake, is actually good about the Good News?

![Jesus stands among his disciples in a scene from the series The Chosen](https://thepulse.org/en/content/images/2026/11/the-chosen-jesus-sendet-seine-juenger-mrj.jpeg)

Jesus and his disciples. Scene from The Chosen, season 3, episode 2\. Photo: [The Chosen](https://watch.angelstudios.com/?ref=thepulse.org)

Far too quickly, people answer this casually with: “The cross.” But the fact that Jesus sent out the Twelve and the 72 with the “gospel,” the good news, should make us think. And back then there wasn’t any cross yet. He also said before his death and resurrection: “It is finished.” Apparently the gospel is already visible in his life before the cross. The cross isn’t everything, even though without the cross, everything is nothing in the end. The gospel goes far beyond our shortening of it to salvation from guilt on the cross.

And that’s the wonderful news:  
There are so many points of connection with today’s society.

The fall (yes, now we’re going way back) wasn’t simply a fall into sin, but at least as much a fall into shame and fear. These are the three great dynamics you can find to different degrees in all sorts of cultures. Adam and Eve felt “guilty” and “accused,” hid out of fear and covered themselves in shame. Christ’s saving work freed us from shame and fear just as much as from guilt. And that creates points of connection for people from all cultures throughout history.

> We just have to learn to play the whole keyboard again, instead of stubbornly hitting our personal favorite key.

### The work of salvation

On the cross, Christ didn’t just save us from our guilt; he set off a whole fireworks display of salvation. Jesus’ life, death and resurrection together make up the one good news, which is made up of many different pieces of good news. All of them show the one Jesus, connecting individually with people’s particular longings and responding to them.

He meets Zacchaeus in his loneliness with closeness and friendship.

He gives dignity to the bent-over woman in her shame.

He talks with the woman at the well about her thirst for real life.

He meets Nicodemus where he is in his search for the meaning of life.

![Jesus and Nicodemus talk at night by lamplight in a scene from the series The Chosen](https://thepulse.org/en/content/images/2026/11/the-chosen-jesus-und-nikodemus-mrj.jpeg)

Jesus and Nicodemus. Scene from The Chosen, season 1, episode 7\. Photo: [The Chosen](https://watch.angelstudios.com/?ref=thepulse.org)

How often he doesn’t say a word about sin, forgiveness or repentance. He only brings up these topics when he senses it’s time, for example with the paralyzed man at the pool of Bethesda or in the conversation afterward with the woman caught in adultery. His different actions are no more interchangeable than his healings or his conversations. Jesus chose his approach depending on the situation and spoke into the longings that were there. That’s exactly the Jesus I love so much.

> If we take this to heart in the same way, we create runways for the gospel with people who feel no point of contact with the word “guilt.”

That leads to moments when the people around us turn around and turn to God, because they experience God’s saving power in their longings.

### Not a threat, but a complement

It’s healing to move ourselves from imbalance back into balance, and to see the aspects of salvation we’ve neglected because of our own one-sidedness no longer as an enemy but as a complement. Without (and I write this with all emphasis) weakening the importance of personal salvation through Christ.

So nothing is lost; rather, things long thought lost are rediscovered and brought back to life. The work of the cross doesn’t fade; it becomes far more colorful and powerful. The gospel can shine out in our world in its unrestrained beauty and truth.

![A man jumps high into the air against a blue sky, seen from below](https://thepulse.org/en/content/images/2026/11/mann-macht-einen-luftsprung-mrj.jpeg)

The gospel can shine out in our world in its unrestrained beauty and truth. (Illustrative photo) Photo: [Vlad Chețan](https://www.pexels.com/photo/low-angle-photography-of-man-jumping-2923156/?ref=thepulse.org)

> So the right movement is hopeful and forward-looking, into a revival of a whole gospel.

If your gospel has become too much of a “stub” to hold, let alone to write with properly, maybe it’s time to make this journey back to the whole gospel that Christ embodied with every pore.